As you know (maybe), Sarah Dessen is my guilty pleasure. Yes, I read certain teen chick lit. I’m not ashamed of it…so there! I am on page 72 of The Moon and More‘s 435 pages and so I’m going to predict what happens. (If you don’t want a spoiler, stop now.) I could be way off base. Then, I’ll write what really happens and see how close I am. Why? Because there’s something to be said for consistency and Sarah Dessen is nothing, if not consistent. You know you’ll get a great teen romance/beach read and for the first 72 pages, nothing has happened to change my mind. So, here goes.
Emaline, just graduated high school, lives in Colby, a resort town. Her grandparents started a summer rental business that she, her mother and her sisters work at. She’s in love with Luke, known him forever and has been going out with him for a few years. VIP renters get a special gift: a cheese/fruit platter and a bottle of wine. It’s Emaline’s job to deliver them. At one house, Sand Dune, she meets a guy her age, but doesn’t really chat. She sees him the next day and they do talk.
Meanwhile, Emaline’s estranged father is in Colby to arrange the sale of his deceased aunt’s house and asks to have dinner with Emaline.
So, the story can go one of two ways: (1) Emaline and unknown boy become friends testing her love for Luke and/or (2) Emaline’s father wants her to move in with him for the summer so she can get to know him and her half-brother, Benji…the separation testing her love for Luke. Somehow, unknown boy inserts himself into this scenario. Anyway, I predict Luke loses and unknown boy wins in the end.
Read on to see how well I did….
OK, so I was close in some respects and a little distant in others. Emaline’s father (as opposed to her dad, who is her adoptive father) is in town for the summer and indeed she does bond with Benji. Does she bond with her father as well? You’ll have to read on.
Of course, unknown boy, Theo, and Emaline do go out. Who wins in the end, Luke or Theo? We’ll both have to read on because I’m 15 pages from the end and I don’t know.
My overall opinion on The Moon and More? It is not my favorite Sarah Dessen book. (I really don’t know which one is.) That much I can say. There are some great characters in Morris and Daisy and Benji. There are some mediocre characters such as her sisters Amber and Margo and her father. There are some really annoying characters, who I won’t mention. The plot and writing are pretty typical Dessen. Regardless of the above,..as I was thinking of why it’s not my favorite book, three things popped into my mind. (1) Compared to all the ‘loner’ characters in Dessen’s books, Theo doesn’t hold up. (2) There’s no music in The Moon and More. I always liked that. And (3) Dessen makes all New Yorkers sound like (as someone close to me says) condescending assholes. As a New Yorker, I resent that.
So, while I have, in the past, given Dessen’s books 5 out of 5 stars, for this one I’m leaning towards 3 1/2 to 4 stars.